Historical Sciences Studies

Current Issue

By Issue

By Author

By Subject

Author Index

Keyword Index

About Journal

Aims and Scope

Editorial Board

Publication Ethics

Indexing and Abstracting

Related Links

FAQ

Peer Review Process

Journal Metrics

News

Cooperation with the association and institute

How to write references and sources

Writers Guide

English work sample

Publication cost

The original form of the work

Conflict of interest form

Sample Persian work

Guide to get Orchid ID

Publons Membership and Review Guide

Reviewers

Mirza Muhammad Akhbari and the Murder of Tsitsianov (A Research on the Relationship between Fath Ali Shah Qajar and Mirza Mohammad Akhbari)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate Department of History, Faculty of Literature and Human Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

2 Professor Department of History, Faculty of Literature and Human Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

10.22059/jhss.2023.364621.473655

Abstract

The competition between the Mujtahids and the Akhbaris to get closer to the political power and the relationship with Qajar Shah is a chapter in the history of the Shiite clergy in the first half of the 13thcentury. The most famous Akhbari scholar in the first 30 years of the 13th century waz Mirza MuhammadAkhbari who had a hard fight with Mujtahids and also got in touch with Fath-Ali Shah Qajar. One of the main reports about Fath Ali Shah's relationship with Mirza Mohammad Akhbari, which in many sources, is at the center of Mirza Mohammad's life narrative, is the story of his role in the murder of Pavel Dmitriyevich Tsitsianov (17054-1806) (commander of the Russian army in the Iran-Russia wars) or its prediction through occult sciences, spell or prayer. The main question of this article is the validity of the narration of Mirza Mohammad's role in the murder of Tsitsianov by examining the history of the narration of this report, identifying inconsistent and alternative narrations, and evaluating some details of the narration with other historical data. Investigating the story of Tsitsianov's murder is important from several points of view. First, this incident is at the center of most of the narratives about the relationship between the Shah and Mirza Mohammad Akhbari; Second This incident has found an important place in the representation of Mirza's personality and the Shah's relationship with Shiite scholars in historical sources and contemporary research, but it has not been carefully examined from a historical point of view. The findings of this research show that some of the important sources of history and biography of Mirza Mohammad Akhbari have not quoted this report or have given data inconsistent with all or part of the popular narrative. evidences also show that the Shah's good relationship with Mirza Muhammad is not only related to the Mirza's power in occult sciences, but Shah knew Mirza Muhammad as one of the reliable Shiite scholars and used him to criticize the opinions of the mujtahids

Keywords

Main Subjects

References
Ābadian, Hossein (2001). Iranian narration of Iran-Russia Wars. Tehran; Center for diplomatic records and history. [In Persian].
Āḡā Bozorg Ṭehrānī, Muḥammad Muḥsin (1983). Ḏarīʿa elā asṣānīf al-šīʿa. edited by Ahmad bin Mohammad Hosseini, Beirut: Dar al-Azwā. [In Arabic].
Āʾīna-ye ḥaqq nemā (2015). Compiled by some students of Ḡofrān-maʾāb, edited by Ali Fazli's, Qom: Shia Bibliography Institute. [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nab (2019), tohfe-ye jahānbānī. edited by k. mohammadhoseini & R. jafarian, twenty-one articles about manuscripts, Journal of the Central Library and Document Center of Tehran University, 15. [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (1923), fatḥ-ul bāb ilā ṭarīq-il ḥaqq-i wa-ṣ ṣawāb. edited dy Ahmad bin mirza abdullā, najaf: Alalavia.[In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (2018), unmuzaj-ol-mortazin. Dar Al Hussein Publication. Retrieved from: https: / /archive. Org / details / 20200713_20200713_1438 [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), collection, No 922, central library of university of Tehran, Tehran. [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), ġamzat-ul burhān li-šubhat-il wasnān. No 389, library and documents center of islamic council, tehran. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), Ḡamzat-ul burhān li- šunhat-il wasnān. No 389, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), ḥaqīqat-ul a‘yān. No 154, Hojjatiya Library, Qom. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), Hijr al molqam, No 2797, library and documents center of islamic council, tehran. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), majāli-il majāli fī šarh-i majāli-l anwār. No 4296, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), radd-e man‘ az šahādat be velāyat-e amīr-al-mo’menīn ‘alī, No 2797, library and documents center of islamic council, Tehran. [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), ṣaḥīfat-u ahl-i ṣafā’ fī ḏikr-i ahl-il ijtibā’ wa-l iṣṭifā’. V1, No 3363, library and documents center of islamic council, Tehran. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), ṣaḥīfat-u ahl-i ṣafā’ fī ḏikr-i ahl-il ijtibā’ wa-l iṣṭifā’. V2, No 7039, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), Tohfe-ye-larie. No 3341, central library of university of Tehran. [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), wamḍat-un nūr, No 3793, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Persian].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), Żiāʾ-ul muttaqīn fī maʾārif-id dīn. No 389, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript), šam-ul haqīqa li man salak-al tariqa. No 154, Hojjatiya Library, Qom. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript). ma‘āwil-ul ‘uqūl fī qal‘-i asās-il uṣūl. No 7050, LibrarY Of Astane Qudse Razavi. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi (Manuscript). Najm-ul wilāya li-man arād-al hidāya. No 549, Hojjatiya Library, Qom. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, mohammad bin Abdul-Nabi, Īqāẓ al-nabih fī ẓīkr mā ajmaʿ alayhi wa īḵtalaf fīh (1937). Edited by Ibrahim bin Mirza Ahmad Jamal al-Din, Al-Tagr Publishing House. [In Arabic].
Aḵbārī, Muhammad bin Abdul-Nabi (2019). Tuhfat Jahanbani, edited by Kamran Muhammad Hosseini and Rasoul Jafarian, Publication of the Central Book of Danishgah of Tehran, Panzdham Notebook. [In Persian].
Āl Jesās, Abul Hasan Ali bin Jafar (n.d). Mārtyr of Hadith. Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/20200713_20200713_1425 [In Arabic].
Algar, hamid (2017). Religion and state in iran 1785 - 1906 the role of ulama, Translated by Abolghasem Serri, Tehran, tous. [In Persian].
Avery, Peter, & Hambly, Gavin, & Melville, Charles (2007). The Cambridge History of Iran. third printing, United Kingdom, Cambridge University press.
Ażod-al-Dawla, Solṭān Aḥmad Mirzā (1997). Tāriḵ-e ażodi, edited by ʿAbd-al-Ḥosayn Navāʾi,  Tehran, Elm. [In Persian].
Badīī, parvīz (1994). Letter of Fath Ali Shah Qajar to his son Abbas Mirza. ganjīne ye asnād, 16, 11-15. [In Persian].
Bakiḵanov, Abbas-Quli-Āga (2003). Golestān-e eram. Tehran: Center for diplomatic records and history. [In Persian].
DEHḴODĀ, Mīrzā ʿALī-akbar qazvīnī (1998), Loḡat-nāme, chief editors: mohammad moʼīn & jaʼfar shahidi, Tehran: Tehran university publication. [In Persian].
Derāyati, Mostafa (2013). Union catalogue of iran manuscripts. Tehran: National library of iran. [In Persian].
Eʿteżād-al-Salṭana,ʿAlīqolī Mīrzā (2016), Eksīr al-tawārīḵ. ed. J. Keyānfar, Tehran, Asāṭīr. [In Persian].
Fasāʼī, Ḥasan Ibn Ḥasan (2004), Tārīḵ-i Fārsnāmah-ye Nāṣerī. Edited by Mansour Rostgar Fasai, Tehran: Amir Kabir [In Persian].
Hadi Deli Al-Moussawi, Shirin (2017). The dispute between the fundamentalists and the Aḵbaris, the scholar Sayyid Mirza Muhammad al- Aḵbārī as a model, Dar Al-Hussein. [In Arabic].
Homā-ye marvazī, mohammad sādeq (Manuscript).tārīḵ-e jahān-ārā. No 2295, National library. [In Persian].
Jafarian,Rasul (2014). Two treatises by Kāshif al-Ghita' against Mirza Mohammad Aḵbari. Tehran, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Persian].
Kashīf al ghaṭa, Muhammad Hussein, al-ʿAbatāt al-ʿAnbarīa fī al-tabaqāt al-jaʿfarīa, edited by Judet Qazvini, Beirut, Beisan. [In Arabic].
Kāẓimī Mūsavī, Aḥmad (2018). ḵāqān ṣāḥib Qirān va ʻulamā-yi zamān, Tehran, Āgāh. [In Persian].
Ḵᵛānsārī, Muḥammad Bāqir(1972). Rawżāt al-ǰannāt, Qom, Ismāʿīlīyān. [In Arabic].
Ḵᵛāvari shirazi (2001). Tariḵ e zol qarnayn, edited by naser afsharfar, Tehran, library and documents center of islamic council. [In Persian].
Maftūn Dunbulī, ʻabd Al-Razzāq (2004), Maʼās̲ir-i sulṭānīyah, edited by Ghulām Ḥusayn Zargarīʹnizhād Tehrān, Iran newspaper publications. [In Persian].
Morshedloo, J. (2019). Double Identity in Favor of Colonial Strategy: Pavel Tsitsianov and the Foundation of Russian Colonialism in South Caucasus (1803-1806). Historical Study of War, 3(2), 129-150. [In Persian].
Mudarris Tabrizi, Muhammad (1995).  Rayḥānat al-adab fi tarājim al-ma'rufin bi l-kunya aw al-laqab,Tehran, Ḵayyām. [In Persian].
Moalem Habib Abadi(1983) , Muhammad Ali, Makarim AL Athar, Isfahan, kamāl.
Nafisi, S. (1956), Social and Political History of Iran in a Contemporary Course, Tehran, Sharq Publications Institution. [In Persian].
Pākravān, Emineh (1997). Abbas Mirza and Fath Ali Shah Qajar, Translated by Safia Rouhi, Tehran, Tariḵ Iran Publishing House. [In Persian]
Raīsnīa, Rahīm(2012), Tsitsianov, Encyclopedia of the Islamic World, edited by Gholam-Ali Haddad-Adel, V25, Tehran,  institution of Encyclopaedia of  the World of Islam. [In Persian].
Sepehr, Moḥammad-Taqī (1925), Nāseḵ al-tawārīḵ. Qājārīya, Edited by Mohammad Baqer Behboodi, Tehran, Islamia bookstore. [In Persian].
Ṭarihi, Muhammad Hussein (1988), Manuscripts of the Treasury of the Jamal al-Din family, Al-Mawsem magazine, 1, 129-161. [In Persian]
Tonokābonī,Moḥammad b. Solaymān(2010), Qeṣaṣ al-ʿolamāʾ, Edited by Mohammadreza Barzegar ḵaleghi and Efat Karbasi, Tehran, Elmifarhangi. [In Persian].
Historical Sciences Studies
Volume 15, Issue 2 - Serial Number 33
September 2023
Pages 85-104
Files
Share
How to cite
Statistics