Historical Sciences Studies

Current Issue

By Issue

By Author

By Subject

Author Index

Keyword Index

About Journal

Aims and Scope

Editorial Board

Publication Ethics

Indexing and Abstracting

Related Links

FAQ

Peer Review Process

Journal Metrics

News

Cooperation with the association and institute

Writers Guide

Sample Persian work

English work sample

Publication cost

The original form of the work

Conflict of interest form

Guide to get Orchid ID

Reviewers

Publons Membership and Review Guide

Vakil al-daula (the Deputy of Kingship) or Vakil al-ra aya (Representative of the People): A Research on the Title of Karim Khan Zand

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate of Iranian history after Islam Tarbiat Modares, ,Tehran, Iran.

2 Associate Professor, Department of History, Tarbiat Modares University,Tehran, Iran.

10.22059/jhss.2024.368072.473670

Abstract

“Karim Khan Zand” is one of the most prominent people who was able to establish his rule over important parts of Iran after the death of “Nader Shah Afshar”. Many stories have been told about his behavior and character in different sources, one of the most important of these quotes is about “Karim Khan Zand”'s title, which means "  Vakil al-ra aya ". Later, many researchers have given many reasons in response to the attribution of this title to “Karim Khan Zand”, which are not consistent with historical documents and sources, and in addition, with the political and social context of Iran's pre-constitutional society. Therefore, the main question of this research is, when was the title " Vakil al-ra aya " used for “Karim Khan” and what are the factors affecting its use? This research answers these questions with a historical method and a descriptive-analytical approach, relying on the content analysis of the documents and the critical study of the historical sources of" the Zand dynasty"  and "Qajar" periods. The results of this research show that the contemporary sources of "Karim Khan Zand" did not mention this title during his lifetime, on the other hand, "Karim Khan Zand" also considered himself as " Vakil al-daula " of ” Ismail III" after the defeat of the claimants. For the first time, under “Majamal al-Tawarikh,”  by “Kohmera” mentions “Karim Khan” with the title of “ Vakil al-ra aya ”, the reason for which was his interest in “Khan Zand” and 's actions for the prosperity and well-being of the people.Also, the writing of the following and referring to this nickname is late from the time of Karim Khan. What is clear is that many researchers consider the title of  Vakil al-ra aya for Karim Khan as a proof of the existence of some kind of political relationship between him and the people, which is a distinct feature of the political order of the modern era. But according to the available documents, it can be said that such a perception cannot represent the type of relationship between the people and the ruler during “the Zand dynasty” period; Because it was with the constitutional revolution that Iranians were able to put aside the old political order and implement a new order based on representation in Iran. Based on this, it can be said that in addition to historical documents, the political structure of Iran during” the Zand dynasty” period could not be a place for such a relationship

Keywords

Main Subjects

References
Adamiyat, Fereydoun and Homa Natiq (2020) Social, political and economic thoughts in the unpublished works of the Qajar era, Tehran, Aghah.[In Persian].
A Chronicle of the Carmelites in Persia)2019) translated by Masoumeh Arbab, Tehran, Nei Publishing. [In Persian].
Anvari, Hassan (1977) Court terms in the Ghaznavid and Seljuq period, Tehran, Tahuri. [In Persian].
Ardeshir Babkan's Karnameh (1950) by Mohammad Javad Mashkoor, Bibi: Chapkhaneh Danesh. [In Persian].
Asif, Mohammad Hashim (1969) Rostam al-Tawarikh, edited by Mohammad Moshiri, Tehran, Amir Kabir. [In Persian].
Avery,Peter(2007) The Cambridge history of Iran, Volume 7, Cambridge University Press,London.
Bammad, Mehdi (1992) Sharh Rejal Iran, Volume 3, Tehran, Zowar. [In Persian].
Chardon, Jean (2013) travel book, translated by Iqbal Yaghmai, volume 2, Tehran, Tus. [In Persian].
Dehghani, Mehdi (2018) The role of the position of Vakil al- Daula in Afshariya and Zandiyeh governments, Research paper on the history of Islamic civilization, year fifty-two, number two, autumn and winter 2018, pp. 2-255. [In Persian].
Donbali, Abd al-Razzaq Bey (1970) The Tajrobato al-Ahrar and Taslia al-Abrar, edited by Hassan Qazi Tabatabai, volumes 1 and 2, Tabriz, Institute of History and Culture of Iran. [In Persian].
Donbali, Abd al-Razzaq Bey (2004), Mather al-Sultanieh, edited by Gholamhossein Zargarinejad, Tehran, Iran Newspaper Publishing Institute. [In Persian].
Estrabadi, Mirza Mehdi Khan (2013), Jahangashai Naderi, edited by Mitra Mehrabadi, Tehran, Duniya Kitab. [In Persian].
Etemad al-Sultaneh (1984), Al-Mathar and Antiquities, by Iraj Afshar, Volume 1, Tehran, Asatir. [In Persian].
Etemad al-Sultaneh (1985), The History of Naseri administrator, edited by Mohammad Esmail Rizvani, Tehran, Duniya Kitab. [In Persian].
Fars Sheriff, Mirza Mohammad (1983), Newspaper, edited by Abbas Iqbal Ashtiani, Tehran, Sanai and Tahuri Library. [In Persian].
Floor, Willem(2001) Safavid Government Institutions, California, Mazda Publishers.
Forster, George(1808) Journey from Bengal to England, Through the Northern part of India, Kashmire, Afghanistan, and Persia, and into Russia by the Caspian-Sea, Vol. II. London: Printed for R. Faulder and son, new Bond_ street.
Franklin, William(none date) Observations made on a tour frome Bengal to Persia etc., London.
Ghafari Kashani, Qazi Ahmad (1983), History of Nagaristan, corrected by Modares Gilani, Tehran, Hafez. [In Persian].
Ghafari-Kashani, Abolhassan (1990), Golshan Murad, under the care of Gholamreza Tabatabai Majd, Tehran, Zarin Publications. [In Persian].
Ghazali, Abu Hamed Mohammad (1938), Nasihat al-Muluk, edited by Jalaluddin Homai, Tehran, Majlis Printing House. [In Persian].
Gmelin, S. Gottlieb (2007), Travels through Northern Persia, 1770-1774, Translated and Annotated by Willem Floor, Costa Mesa: Mage Publishers.
Gmelin, S. Gottlieb (2013), Journey to Northern Iran, translated by Gholamhossein Sadri Afshar, Rasht, Farhang Ilia. [In Persian].
Golestaneh, Abolhasan bin Mohammad Amin (1976), Majamal al-Tawarikh, corrected by Mohammad Taghi Modares Razavi, Tehran, Tehran University Press. [In Persian].
Hedayat, Reza Qoli Khan (2001), Rowzah al-Safa, by Jamshid Kianfar, Volume 9, Tehran, Asatir. [In Persian].
Hedayati, Hadi (1955), History of Zandiyeh, Tehran, Tehran University Press. [In Persian].
Hosseini Ameli, Mohammad Shafi)2004)Mahafel al-Momenin fel al-Majales Momenin, by Ibrahim Arabpour and Mansour Joghtaei, Mashhad, Astan Quds Razavi, Islamic Research Foundation. [In Persian].
Hosseini Dashti, Syed Mustafi (2006), Maarif and Maarif, Volume 5, Tehran, Arayeh Cultural Institute. [In Persian].
Hosseini Fasaei, Mirza Hassan (1988), Farsnameh Naseri, corrected and revised by Mansour Rostgar Fasaei, volume 1, Tehran, Amir Kabir. [In Persian].
Khatunabadi, Seyyed Abdul Hossein Hosseini (1973) Vaqai al-Senin and Al-Awam, by Mohammad Baqer Behboudi, Tehran, Islamia. [In Persian].
https://www.qdl.qa/en/search/site/carim%2520caun.
Ibn Jama'ah, Badr al-Din (1984), Tahreer al-Ahkam fi al-Tadbir Ahl al-Islam, researched by Fawad Abd al-Moneim Ahmad, Qatar, head of courts. [In Arabic].
Iqbal Chalavi, Mirza Ali, Malik Ara, Majlis Library, 10-18368. [In Persian].
Itzad al-Sultaneh, Ali Qali Mirza (1990), Aksir al-Tawarikh, with the efforts of Jamshid Kianfar, Tehran, Weisman. [In Persian].
Jazayeri, Seyyed Abdullah (Bita), Shushtar Tadzkare, Bija, Heydari Printing House. [In Persian].
Jones, Harford (1976), The Last Days of Lotf Ali Khan Zand, translated by Homa Natiq and John Gurney, Tehran, Amir Kabir. [In Persian].
Khandamir, Ghiyath al-Din bin Hamam al-Din (1954), Habib al-Sir in the news of human beings, under the supervision of Mohammad Dabir Siyaghi, volume 4, Tehran, Khayyam. [In Persian].
Khanji, Fazllullah bin Rozbahan (1976), Mehman Nameh Bukhara, by the efforts of Manouchehr Sotoudeh, Tehran, publishing and translation company. [In Persian].
Kohmera, Zain al-Abidin (2005), Resaleh Tadebir Shah and Vazir, edited by Mehin Dekht Hajianpour, University Press, Tehran. [In Persian].
Lahiji, Mohammad Ali Hazin (1953), History of Hazin, Isfahan, Affirm Bookstore. [In Persian].
Lotfi, Asadullah (2014), Translation of the legal topics of Shahr al-Ma'ah, Tehran, Majd. [In Persian].
Malkom, Sir Jan (2001), History of Iran, translated by Mirza Ismail Hirat, Volume 2, Tehran, Duniya Kitab. [In Persian].
Marashi Safavi, Mirza Mohammad Khalil (1983), Majmam al-Tawarikh, corrected by Abbas Iqbal, Tehran, Tahuri. [In Persian].
Mawardi, Abi al-Hassan (1988), Ahkam al-Sultaniyyah, researched by Ahmed Mubarak Baghdadi, Kuwait, Dar Ibn Qutiba. [In Arabic].
Mirza Sami'a, Muhammad Sami (2008), Tazkra Al-Muluk, by the effort of Seyyed Mohammad Dabir Siyaghi, translated by Masoud Rajabnia, Tehran, Amir Kabir. [In Persian].
Mostofi, Mohammad Mohsen (1996), Zabdeh Al-Tavarikh, Behrouz Goderzi effort, Tehran, Dr. Mahmoud Afshar Endowment Foundation. [In Persian].
Naini, Muhammad Jafar bin Muhammad Hossein (1974), Jame Jafari, by the efforts of Iraj Afshar, Tehran, National Art Association. [In Persian].
Nami Esfahani, Mirza Mohammad Sadegh Mousavi (1987), Giti Gosha History, edited by Saeed Nafisi, Tehran, Iqbal. [In Persian].
Navaei, Abdul Hossein (2012), Karim Khan Zand, Tehran, Elmi and farhangi. [In Persian].
Niebor, Carsten (2010), Travel book, translated by Parviz Rajabi, Tehran, Iranshenasi. [In Persian].
Nizam al-Mulk, Hasan bin Ali (2007), Sir al-Muluk; Policy, Tehran, Ferdous. [In Persian].
Onsor al-Ma'ali, Kikaus bin Iskandar (1956), Qaboos Nameh, edited by Amin Abdul Hamid Badavi, Tehran, Ibn Sina bookstore. [In Persian].
Perry, John. R. (1986), Karimkhan Zand, translated by Ali Mohammad Saki, Tehran, Faraz. [In Persian].
Qazvini, Abolhassan (1990), Fawaid al-Safawieh, edited by Maryam Mirahmadi, Tehran, Institute of Cultural Studies and Research. [In Persian].
Rajabi, Parviz (2008), Karim Khan Zand and his time, Tehran, Akhtaran. [In Persian].
Rawandi, Morteza (1975), Social History of Iran, Volume 2, Tehran, Amir Kabir. [In Persian].
Razi, Najm (2004), Mursad al-Abad, by Mohammad Amin Riahi, Tehran, Elmi and Farhangi. [In Persian].
Saadi, Moslehuddin (2018), Golestan, edited by Mohammad Ali Foroughi, Tehran, Qoqnos. [In Persian].
Sabzevari, researcher (2002), Al-Anwar Abbasi Mosque, with the effort of Najaf Lak Zaei, Bostan Kitab, Qom. [In Persian].
Saravi, Muhammad Fethullah bin Muhammad Taqi (1991), Muhammadan History, by the efforts of Gholamreza Tabatabai Majd, Tehran, Amir Kabir. [In Persian].
Sepehr, Mohammad Taqi-lasan-al-Molk (1998), The transcription of the annals, by the efforts of Jamshidkian Far, volumes 1 and 2, Tehran, Asatir. [In Persian].
Shabani, Reza (2014), History of political-social developments in the Afsharia and Zandiyeh periods, Tehran, Samt. [In Persian].
Shirazi, Ibn Abdul Karim Ali Reza (1986), History of Zandiyeh, edited by Ernst Beyer, Tehran, Gostareh. [In Persian].
Siori, Roger (2013), Safavid Iran, Kambiz Azizi, Tehran, Center. [In Persian].
Tanhatan Naseri, Iraj (2003), The issue of sovereignty and its legitimacy during the reign of Karim Khan Zand, number 3, Anthropology Research Journal. [In Persian].
Tavernier, Jean-Baptiste (2010), Travel Book, translated by Hamid Afshar Shirvani, Tehran, Nilufar. [In Persian].
Tusi, Muhammad bin Al-Hassan (2002), Al-Ghaibah, Ali Akbar Al-Ghafari, Beirut, Al-Fajr. [In Arabic].
Vahid Qazvini, Mohammad Taher (2003), History of Jahan Arai Abbasi, by the effort of Saeed Mir Mohammad Sadiq, Tehran, Research Institute of Humanities. [In Persian].
Varharam, Gholamreza (2006), Iran's political and social history in the Zand era, Tehran, Moin. [In Persian].
Zargarinejad, Gholamhossein (2018), Thought and Politics in Qajar Iran,.Volume 1, Tehran, Andisheh Nagaristan. [In Persian].
Historical Sciences Studies
Volume 16, Issue 1 - Serial Number 37
August 2024
Pages 127-154
Files
Share
How to cite
Statistics